What is fiduciary liability insurance?
Fiduciary liability insurance covers claims against the organization and against individuals alleging a breach of fiduciary duty in the administration of an employee benefit plan, including imprudent investment selection, excessive fees, failure to follow plan documents, improper eligibility determinations, and errors in enrollment or distribution. The exposure comes from the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, which imposes a high standard of care on anyone with discretionary authority over plan assets or administration. That standard is often described as the highest known to law. Critically, ERISA makes fiduciaries personally liable to restore losses to the plan. A board member who sits on an investment committee, a chief financial officer who selects a recordkeeper, a human resources director who administers enrollment, and sometimes a board as a whole can all be fiduciaries, and the title on the org chart does not control. Functional conduct does. That is why fiduciary liability is one of the few coverages where the individuals have as much at stake as the organization.
- Imprudent selection or monitoring of plan investments
- Excessive recordkeeping, administrative, or investment fees
- Failure to follow the written plan document
- Enrollment, eligibility, and distribution errors
- Failure to remit employee contributions timely
- Improper plan changes or termination decisions
Is this not covered by our D&O policy?
No. Nearly every nonprofit D&O policy contains an ERISA or benefit plan exclusion, specifically because fiduciary liability is a distinct insurable risk with its own pricing. Some management liability packages bundle a fiduciary coverage part alongside D&O and employment practices liability, which is a good structure, but bundled does not mean automatic. The coverage part has to be present, and it frequently carries its own sublimit. Check three things in your current program. Whether a fiduciary liability coverage part exists at all, and if so, its limit, which in small nonprofit packages is often $250,000 or $500,000 rather than the full policy limit. Whether it includes voluntary compliance program coverage, which pays the costs of correcting an error through the Internal Revenue Service and Department of Labor voluntary correction programs, since self-correction is the most common real-world use of this policy. And whether it includes HIPAA and health plan privacy penalties, which arise from the health and welfare side and are increasingly relevant. Many small organizations discover the gap only when a recordkeeper asks for evidence of fiduciary coverage during a plan transition.
What is an ERISA fidelity bond and why is it not enough?
An ERISA fidelity bond is required by federal law and protects the plan against theft by the people handling its assets; it does not protect you against claims that you made bad decisions. The two are routinely confused, and the confusion leaves boards uninsured for the exposure they actually face. The bond requirement is specific. Every person who handles plan funds must be bonded for at least ten percent of the funds handled, with a minimum of $1,000 and a maximum generally of $500,000, or $1 million for plans holding employer securities. The bond names the plan as the insured and pays the plan when a covered person commits fraud or dishonesty. Fiduciary liability insurance is the mirror image: it names the organization and the individual fiduciaries as insureds and pays when they are accused of breaching their duties. One protects the plan from your people. The other protects your people from the plan's participants. A plan audit will ask for the bond. Only a claim will ask for the fiduciary policy, and by then it is too late to buy it.
- ERISA bond: required by law, protects the plan from theft, minimum ten percent of funds handled
- Fiduciary liability: optional but important, protects fiduciaries from breach claims
- The bond pays the plan; the policy pays your defense and liability
- A plan audit checks for the bond, not for fiduciary coverage
Why are small nonprofits being sued over plan fees?
Because excessive fee litigation that began against very large plans has moved steadily downmarket, and plan size no longer provides the protection it did a decade ago. The core allegation is straightforward: the fiduciaries failed to monitor fees, left expensive share classes in place when identical cheaper ones were available, failed to benchmark recordkeeping costs, or kept underperforming investment options without documented review. For a 403(b) plan at a mid-size nonprofit, the facts that create exposure are common and fixable. Legacy annuity products with layered fees. Retail share classes where institutional classes are available at the same asset level. Recordkeeping paid through revenue sharing that nobody has benchmarked in five years. No investment policy statement, or one adopted in 2014 and never applied. No documented committee meetings. The defense in these cases is almost entirely procedural. Courts examine whether the fiduciaries had a prudent process, not whether the investment outcome was good. An organization with quarterly committee minutes, a current investment policy statement, documented fee benchmarking every two to three years, and evidence that it acted on what it found is in a materially different position than one with no paper at all. Fiduciary insurance pays for the defense. The process is what makes the defense winnable.
What should a nonprofit do this quarter?
Take five concrete steps, none of which require a consultant to begin: identify your fiduciaries in writing, confirm your ERISA bond amount, confirm whether you have fiduciary liability coverage and at what limit, charter a benefits committee with a meeting schedule, and benchmark your plan fees. Start by listing every person with discretionary authority over the plan and documenting it in a board resolution, because unidentified fiduciaries are still fiduciaries and undocumented delegation is a defense you cannot use. Then verify the bond covers ten percent of plan assets handled and that it has been updated as the plan grew, since a bond written when the plan held $900,000 is inadequate at $4 million. Next, read your management liability policy for a fiduciary coverage part and its sublimit, and ask about voluntary compliance program coverage. Charter the committee with a simple written charter, meet at least semiannually, and keep minutes that show what was reviewed and what was decided, including decisions to make no change. Finally, benchmark. A fee benchmarking exercise comparing your all-in plan cost to peer plans of similar size is the single most useful document a nonprofit fiduciary can hold, and it is what a plaintiff's attorney will ask whether you ever did. Also confirm contribution remittance timing, since late deposit of employee deferrals is the most frequently cited fiduciary violation in Department of Labor investigations and it is entirely an operations problem.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
This article is for general information and is not a substitute for policy language or professional advice.
