Can a board member be sued personally if the nonprofit is a corporation?

Yes. Incorporation protects directors from the organization's contractual debts, but it does not stop a plaintiff from naming individual directors in a lawsuit alleging breach of fiduciary duty, mismanagement, or a wrongful employment decision. Once named, each director needs a defense, and the cost of that defense begins immediately regardless of how the case eventually resolves.

Does our general liability policy cover the board?

No, and this is the most common misunderstanding in nonprofit insurance. General liability covers bodily injury and property damage, such as a visitor who falls at your office or an event. Claims about decisions, votes, financial oversight, and employment are financial harm rather than physical harm, and they fall outside general liability entirely, which is why a separate D&O policy is necessary.

We are an all volunteer organization with no employees. Do we still need D&O?

Usually yes, because the exposures that generate nonprofit claims do not require payroll. Donors, members, grantors, other board members, and state regulators can all bring claims about how the organization was governed and how funds were handled. All volunteer organizations are also the least able to absorb a defense bill, and coverage at a $1,000,000 limit is often priced under $1,500 a year.

How does a state attorney general inquiry work, and is it covered?

State attorneys general and charities bureaus have authority to investigate whether a nonprofit is being run consistently with its charitable purpose, and an inquiry usually begins with a written request for financial records, board minutes, and governance documents. Most current nonprofit D&O forms cover the legal costs of responding, but coverage language varies, and some older forms require a formal proceeding rather than an informal inquiry. Ask your broker to confirm that informal regulatory investigations trigger coverage on your specific form.

Who exactly is insured under a nonprofit D&O policy?

Typically the organization itself, current and former directors and officers, employees, and in most forms volunteers and committee members acting on the organization's behalf. Coverage usually extends to the estates and spouses of insured individuals for claims arising from their service. Confirm the definition of insured in writing, especially if you rely heavily on volunteers or use an advisory board, because definitions vary meaningfully between carriers.

Nonprofit Directors and Officers Insurance: What Actually Protects Your Board

Key Takeaways

Nonprofit D&O covers breach of fiduciary duty, misuse of restricted gifts, bylaw violations, and the cost of responding to a state attorney general or charities bureau inquiry.
Volunteer immunity statutes do not pay defense costs, generally exclude employment claims, and rarely protect compensated staff such as an executive director.
Bylaw indemnification is only as strong as the organization's balance sheet, and Side A coverage exists precisely for when the nonprofit cannot or may not indemnify.
Employment allegations drive roughly 60 to 75 percent of nonprofit D&O claims, which is why nearly every nonprofit form bundles employment practices liability.
Fiduciary liability for retirement and health plans is a separate coverage from D&O and from the ERISA fidelity bond, and often runs $600 to $2,500 a year.
A $1,000,000 limit commonly costs $600 to $1,500 for an all volunteer nonprofit and $2,500 to $8,000 for an organization with fifteen to fifty employees.

What does nonprofit directors and officers insurance actually cover?

Nonprofit D&O covers claims alleging a wrongful act in the governance and management of the organization, including breach of fiduciary duty, mismanagement of funds, failure to follow your own bylaws, and misuse of restricted donations. It pays defense costs, settlements, and judgments, and defense costs are usually the larger number.

The claims are rarely dramatic. A board overspends an endowment's spending policy. Two directors are accused of steering a contract to a company one of them owns. The organization dips into a restricted building fund to cover payroll and a donor finds out.

Regulatory matters count too. Most current forms cover the cost of responding to an inquiry from a state attorney general or charities bureau, which is often where a governance problem surfaces first. Confirm your form includes investigation costs, since older ones require a formal proceeding first.

Breach of fiduciary duty claims brought by members, donors, or the state
Alleged misuse or commingling of restricted gifts and grant funds
Failure to follow bylaws in elections, removals, or major transactions
Defense of an attorney general or charities bureau inquiry into governance

Why are volunteer immunity laws and our bylaws not enough?

Volunteer immunity statutes and bylaw indemnification do not pay legal fees, and legal fees are what actually bankrupt a board member. Immunity laws in most states protect uncompensated volunteers from personal liability for ordinary negligence, but they do not stop anyone from filing suit and they do not fund the defense that gets the case dismissed.

Those statutes also have real holes. They typically exclude willful misconduct, gross negligence, acts outside the scope of duties, and employment claims. They rarely protect a paid executive director, and they protect the individual rather than the organization, which stays fully exposed.

Indemnification in your bylaws is a promise from the organization to reimburse a director, and it is only as good as the balance sheet behind it. A nonprofit facing a six figure defense bill often cannot pay, and is sometimes legally barred from indemnifying at all, which is exactly when a director's personal assets are exposed.

Immunity statutes generally do not cover employment claims, the most common suits
Immunity almost never extends to compensated staff, including the executive director
Neither protection funds a defense at the moment the complaint arrives

What is the difference between entity coverage and Side A?

Entity coverage protects the organization itself when it is named in a claim, while Side A protects individual directors and officers when the organization cannot or will not indemnify them. A complete nonprofit D&O policy includes both, plus Side B, which reimburses the organization when it does indemnify.

The distinction only matters when it matters most. If your nonprofit dissolves or is barred from indemnifying, Side B has nothing to reimburse and entity coverage is busy defending the organization. Side A is what stands between a former board member and their own savings.

Larger or higher profile organizations sometimes buy a separate Side A excess policy dedicated to individuals. For most small and midsize nonprofits, the practical step is confirming Side A is in the base form and that entity defense costs cannot erode the limit to nothing.

Why do most nonprofit D&O policies include employment practices coverage?

Most nonprofit D&O policies bundle employment practices liability because employment claims are what nonprofits actually get sued for, and carriers price the two together for that reason. Employment allegations commonly drive 60 to 75 percent of nonprofit D&O claims.

Employment practices liability covers wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, retaliation, and hostile work environment allegations brought by employees, former employees, and applicants. Nonprofits are exposed in particular ways: thin or absent HR staffing, boards that involve themselves directly in personnel decisions, and a mission driven culture where people speak frankly and document poorly.

Watch two limitations. The employment section usually shares the policy limit and carries its own higher retention, often $2,500 to $25,000 depending on staff count. Volunteers and independent contractors are not always inside the definition of employee, which matters if you run on volunteers.

Confirm volunteers and interns are named as insureds under the employment section
Check the employment retention separately; it is usually higher than the D&O retention
Ask whether third party harassment claims by clients or vendors are included

Do we need fiduciary liability if we offer a retirement plan?

Yes, if your organization sponsors a retirement plan or a health plan, because fiduciary liability is a separate coverage that D&O does not provide. Fiduciary liability protects the people who administer employee benefit plans from claims that they selected poor investments, charged excessive fees, or failed to follow the plan document.

Nonprofits often assume the plan's recordkeeper carries this, but the recordkeeper is not the fiduciary. Your executive director, finance director, and any board members on a retirement committee are, and their exposure is personal.

An ERISA fidelity bond is a different requirement and no substitute. The bond covers theft from the plan and is generally required at 10 percent of plan assets. Fiduciary liability covers mistakes in judgment and administration, and often runs $600 to $2,500 a year for a small plan.

Fiduciary liability covers plan administration errors; the ERISA bond covers plan theft
Board members on an investment or retirement committee are personally exposed
Document your process for reviewing plan fees and fund lineups at least annually

What happens to our coverage when we switch carriers?

D&O is written on a claims made basis, which means the policy that pays is the one in force when the claim is made, not when the act occurred. That makes your prior acts date, sometimes called the retroactive date, the single most important item on the declarations page when you change carriers.

If a new carrier sets the retroactive date at the new policy's start, everything your board did before that date is uninsured, no matter how long you carried coverage. Ask for full prior acts, or at minimum a retroactive date matching your original inception.

Two habits protect continuity. Report circumstances that could become claims before you switch, since the old policy covers what was reported to it. If you let coverage lapse or wind the organization down, buy an extended reporting period, one to six years at 75 to 200 percent of annual premium.

Confirm the retroactive date on every renewal and every carrier change
Report known circumstances to the expiring carrier before the policy ends
Buy tail coverage if you dissolve, merge, or drop the policy
Keep expired policies indefinitely, since claims surface years later

What limits and premiums are typical for a small or midsize nonprofit?

Most small nonprofits carry a $1,000,000 D&O limit, midsize organizations carry $2,000,000 to $5,000,000, and organizations with significant assets, government contracts, or large staffs go higher. Limits are usually shared with the employment section, so a large employment claim can consume the protection your board is counting on.

Premiums track budget and headcount more than mission. An all volunteer nonprofit under $500,000 in revenue with no employees commonly pays $600 to $1,500 a year for $1,000,000. An organization with $1,000,000 to $5,000,000 in revenue and fifteen to fifty employees typically pays $2,500 to $8,000. Retentions usually run $1,000 to $5,000, with a higher employment retention.

Grantmakers increasingly ask about D&O before releasing funds, and strong board candidates ask before accepting a seat.

Ask whether D&O and employment share one limit or carry separate limits
Compare quotes on retention and defense terms, not premium alone
Confirm whether defense costs are paid outside the limit
Revisit limits when revenue, staff, or grant funding grows materially

Frequently Asked Questions

This article is for general information and is not a substitute for policy language or professional advice.

Back to All Insights